Latest News  

UK: Outsourcing is leaving public sector bodies financially exposed

The trend towards ever-greater outsourcing is putting vital public services in the hands of potentially unstable conglomerates but leaving public bodies with the asset risk, argues Colin Haslam.

2015-11-05 14:25:32

From the 1980s onwards, the UK government has employed contracting out to provide public services. The National Audit Office estimates that the government spends £187bn on buying in goods and services. It is difficult to separate out service outsourcing from traditional goods procurement in the official statistics but it is clear that government spending with third parties continues to expand, especially at local government level, Haslam writes on the London School of Economics and Political Sciences' blog.

The advocates of outsourcing view contracting out as a way to reform public services, improve efficiency and generate value for money. Outsourcing contracts are announced in press along with the claim that millions will be saved. However, the extent to which these contracts are delivering value for money and reducing costs is difficult to assess because contract details are generally withheld on grounds of commercial confidentiality.

A further complication is that local and national government agencies are contracting with outsourcers that consolidate many contracts into portfolios. These are often large conglomerates or specialist firms, some of which are British companies, others subsidiaries of foreign multinationals or private equity holding companies. This accumulation of many contracts within a few large firms forces national and local government agencies into a dependency relationship because they no longer have the operating capacity to deliver public services. This dependency is reinforced because many outsourced contracts are for the provision of foundational economy services such as health, adult care, welfare, and household waste management that are essential for a civilised life.

Conglomerates like Serco or G4S manage hundreds of diverse contracts for UK national and local government agencies. Serco and G4S are in a constant struggle to find growth to secure additional profit and this means capturing new contracts, winning renewals in a competitive market, and turbo-charging growth through the acquisition of other firms. These firms chase revenue and profits but this strategy also inflates their balance sheets: liabilities in terms of debt outstanding and goodwill representing the difference between the market and book value of acquisitions. Increased pressure to win new contracts and keep delivering growth for investors has resulted in poor judgements over the choice of new contracts, what to renew and what firms to acquire.

Mistakes and misunderstandings resulted in a £1.6bn write down in the value of Serco's assets forcing an intensive restructuring strategy.
Even contracting out specialists such as Biffa and Veolia are under pressure to generate financial leverage and boost shareholder returns from contracts with the public sector. Biffa, a household waste management company had to write down roughly £1bn of debt finance to restructure its over-capitalised balance sheet. Veolia UK, another specialist operator, is under pressure from its French parent company to generate returns.

According to International Public Sector Accounting Standards, off-loading responsibility for the management of contracts to the private sector does not involve transferring the responsibility for asset value risk to the operator responsible. Assets attached to an outsourcing contract will still be reported on the public sector accounts where the public sector entity either regulates the contract or can take up ownership of the assets at the end of the contract. Public sector reporting entities, as a consequence, are exposed to fair value impairment risks to these assets, which could undermine reported net worth leaving taxpayers to foot the bill.

Outsourcing of public services creates new problems and risks. Public sector expertise and capacity to deliver essential services are being hollowed out. Foundational services, upon which we all depend, are transferred to conglomerates and specialists prone to financial instability and collapse. Public sector reporting entities in the meantime are not able to transfer asset risk associated with their outsourced contracts leaving them exposed to impairments that could undermine their financials.

Colin Haslam is professor of accounting and finance at Queen Mary University of London


0 COMMENTS ^ Go back to Top
WRITE A COMMENT ^ Go back to Top
 
Your email address will not be published.
Nickname
Email
Comment
Validation Code
   
 
 
NEWS
Coface opens a regional IT development center in Bucharest and launches recruitment drive for 80 specialists

The Coface Group, expert in credit insurance, will be opening an IT development center in Bucharest at the beginning of April, employing 80 people.

 Read Full article »
CA Technologies acquired Veracode

CA Technologies on Monday announced it's acquiring Veracode, a SaaS-based secure devOps platform provider, for approximately 614 million US dollars in cash. The deal is expected to close in Q1 of fiscal year 20

 Read Full article »
Logicom launched Cloud Marketplace platform in Romania

Logicom, one of the leading distributors of IT solutions and services and Microsoft Cloud Solution provider, announced the launch of Cloud Marketplace platform in Romania.

 Read Full article »
Excelian Luxoft Financial Services strengthens Its APAC presence with the acquisition of derivIT

Luxoft Holding, leading provider of software development services and innovative IT solutions to a global client base, announced that it has entered into a Share Purchase Agreement to acquire derivIT, a Singapo

 Read Full article »
SAP: Only four percent of companies offer customer experience based on contextual data to clients

According to latest findings of business and technology software solutions provider SAP conducted together with CMO Council, only four percent of companies offer real time customer experience based on contextua

 Read Full article »
Manpower: One out of three Romanian companies will hire people in second quarter, 2017

About a third of employers in Romania anticipate an increase of the number of employees in the second quarter of 2017, while only 7 per cent of company representatives foresee a drop of personnel, according to

 Read Full article »
Luxoft depicts top five global trends in software in 2017

According to the latest findings of software and It solutions provider Luxoft, transforming industries and business models within the context of accelerated innovation and strengthened disruptive technologies p

 Read Full article »
Oracle surpasses 9 billion US dollars worth revenues globally

Oracle Corporation announced fiscal 2017 Q3 results with total revenues up to 9.2 billion US dollars, a 2 per cent increase in US dollars and up 3 per cent increase in constant currency, the financial report st

 Read Full article »
Accenture Research: Three critical accelerators to closing the gender pay gap for class of 2020

Women graduating from university in developed markets in 2020 could be the first generation to close the gender pay gap in their professional lifetimes, according to new research from Accenture

 Read Full article »
CA Technologies positioned a leader for identity governance and administration

CA Technologies (NASDAQ:CA) has been positioned by Gartner, Inc., in the Leaders quadrant of the 2017 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Identity Governance and Administration (IGA).

 Read Full article »
 
MOST RECENT VIDEO
 
 
MOST READ ARTICLES
» ROMANIAN OUTSOURCING AWARDS FOR EXCELL...
» Luxoft surged 40 per cent in 2015 – ...
» Exclusive OT print issue: Genpact may ...
» Manpower:Romania has world's third hig...
» SocGen's EBS division to grow 60%, exp...
» Bombardier: from Bucharest subway to t...
» People in Shared Services and Outsourc...
» Omnichannel: 4 pillars of a purposeful...
» Companies such as Endava and Fortech d...
» DB Global Technology: 40 per cent of t...
 
EDITOR CHOICE
TELUS International Europe: More proactive, personalized customer experience, thanks to the Internet of Things (IoT)

Industry research is apt to say we're on the cusp of a future full of "smart" devices — that is, billions of everyday items embedded with wireless internet connectivity

 Read Full article »
Romanian Outsourcing Summit: Focus on the added-value of business shared services in Romania

This year's edition of Romanian Outsourcing Summit joined representatives of the government and top representatives of leading companies operating in the sector of business shared services and related industrie

 Read Full article »
Romanian Outsourcing Summit reaches its third edition

OUTSOURCING TODAY, the integrated communication platform of the business services sector, powered by The Diplomat Bucharest, presents the Third Edition of the ROMANIAN OUTSOURCING SUMMIT on March 23rd 2017, at

 Read Full article »
The most critical Key Performance Indicator (KPI) in social media customer service

Measuring the impact that your social media interactions are having on your business — and your bottom line — can be a tricky endeavor. How can you really identify and quantify whether a particular social m

 Read Full article »
SAP employees to teach programming to scholars in Cluj-Napoca

Ten volunteers working for SAP company together with Cartea Daliei association will organize a Scratch programming teaching club to function at Emil Isac school based in Cluj-Napoca, the company announced.

 Read Full article »
Latest News  
 
about us | newsletter | contact | members area
Copyright © 2015 by Diplomat Media Events Design by Diplomat Media Events